Index » Working Group Ballot of P802.1ap/D3.0
| Tallied Votes | Other Information | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Approve [*] | 7 (%37) | Pass / Fail [**] | Fail |
| Disapprove | 12 (%63) | Last Updated | 2007-11-13 |
| Abstain [*] | 56 (%75) | Non-Voting Comments [*] | 1 |
| Total | 75 | Participation |  75 / 91  5 |
* Approve includes "Comments With Approve"
Abstain includes "Comments With Abstain"
Non-Voting Comments are just "Comments"
Abstain includes "Comments With Abstain"
Non-Voting Comments are just "Comments"
** To "Pass": Approval Percent >= 75% and Work Group Parcipation >= 50%
Ballot Votes
| Participant | Vote | Date | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Karen Randall | |
Abstain | Mon Oct 08 09:01:47 2007 |
| John Nels Fuller | |
Abstain | Tue Oct 09 14:37:57 2007 |
| Anoop Ghanwani | |
Abstain | Tue Oct 09 15:48:54 2007 |
| Keti Kilcrease (kilcreas) | |
Abstain | Tue Oct 09 17:27:30 2007 |
| Jan Bialkowski | |
Abstain | Wed Oct 10 16:32:21 2007 |
| Muneyoshi Suzuki | |
Abstain | Tue Oct 16 05:06:01 2007 |
| Mike Ko | |
Abstain | Tue Oct 16 15:22:23 2007 |
| Geoffrey M. Garner | |
Abstain | Tue Oct 16 15:35:20 2007 |
| David James | |
Disapprove | Tue Oct 16 18:08:36 2007 |
| HongKyu Jeong | |
Abstain | Tue Oct 16 20:58:44 2007 |
| Raghu Kondapalli | |
Abstain | Fri Oct 19 20:07:02 2007 |
| Gunther, Craig | |
Abstain | Mon Oct 22 12:13:05 2007 |
| Olsen, Dave | |
Abstain | Mon Oct 22 13:00:42 2007 |
| Michael Wright | |
Approve | Mon Oct 22 13:16:13 2007 |
| Menu Menuchehry | |
Abstain | Mon Oct 22 13:45:06 2007 |
| Sauer, John M. | |
Abstain | Mon Oct 22 15:50:53 2007 |
| Roese, Josef | |
Abstain | Tue Oct 23 07:11:42 2007 |
| Hiroshi Ohta | |
Abstain | Wed Oct 24 01:17:06 2007 |
| LE GOFF Yannick RD-RESA-LAN | |
Abstain | Thu Oct 25 20:32:21 2007 |
| BONNAMY Jean-michel RD-RESA-LAN | |
Abstain | Fri Oct 26 04:07:21 2007 |
| VISSERS Maarten | |
Abstain | Fri Oct 26 10:34:07 2007 |
| Robert Roden | |
Abstain | Wed Oct 31 06:42:54 2007 |
| Marco Mascitto | |
Abstain | Wed Oct 31 08:16:58 2007 |
| Don Pannell | |
Abstain | Wed Oct 31 17:40:12 2007 |
| Zehavit Alon | |
Disapprove | Thu Nov 01 10:51:39 2007 |
| Alan McGuire | |
Abstain | Fri Nov 02 07:43:04 2007 |
| Feifei Feng | |
Abstain | Sat Nov 03 21:26:50 2007 |
| Hal Keen | |
Abstain | Sun Nov 04 16:19:52 2007 |
| Dennis Volpano | |
Abstain | Sun Nov 04 18:04:08 2007 |
| Shlomo Ovadia | |
Abstain | Sun Nov 04 22:18:35 2007 |
| Bruce Kwan | |
Abstain | Mon Nov 05 01:54:03 2007 |
| Brandner, Rudolf (NSN - DE/Munich) | |
Disapprove | Mon Nov 05 07:44:43 2007 |
| Tony Jeffree | |
Comments (With Approve) | Mon Nov 05 10:16:07 2007 |
| Brian Hassink | |
Abstain | Mon Nov 05 10:31:21 2007 |
| Haim Porat | |
Abstain | Mon Nov 05 10:39:11 2007 |
| Osama Aboul-Magd | |
Abstain | Mon Nov 05 10:48:44 2007 |
| Stanton, Kevin B | |
Abstain | Mon Nov 05 12:34:58 2007 |
| Attila Takacs | |
Abstain | Mon Nov 05 13:17:54 2007 |
| Henry (Chien-Hsien) Wu | |
Abstain | Mon Nov 05 22:31:55 2007 |
| Claudio DeSanti | |
Approve | Tue Nov 06 03:28:13 2007 |
| INSLER Romain RD-RESA-LAN | |
Abstain | Tue Nov 06 03:38:25 2007 |
| Alex Conta | |
Abstain | Tue Nov 06 04:14:36 2007 |
| Winkel, Ludwig | |
Abstain | Tue Nov 06 09:24:44 2007 |
| Kevin Nolish | |
Comments (With Abstain) | Tue Nov 06 10:33:42 2007 |
| Romascanu, Dan (Dan) | |
Disapprove | Tue Nov 06 11:43:35 2007 |
| Eric Gray | |
Abstain | Tue Nov 06 16:05:12 2007 |
| Stephen Haddock | |
Abstain | Tue Nov 06 16:30:13 2007 |
| Bob Frazier | |
Abstain | Tue Nov 06 16:49:27 2007 |
| Linda Dunbar | |
Abstain | Tue Nov 06 17:41:05 2007 |
| SETO, Koichiro | |
Abstain | Tue Nov 06 18:10:05 2007 |
| Francois Tallet (ftallet) | |
Abstain | Tue Nov 06 19:50:23 2007 |
| Mick Seaman | |
Abstain | Tue Nov 06 20:30:32 2007 |
| Norman Finn (nfinn) | |
Disapprove | Tue Nov 06 20:53:34 2007 |
| Wadekar, Manoj K | |
Approve | Tue Nov 06 21:54:41 2007 |
| Joseph Salowey (jsalowey) | |
Disapprove | Wed Nov 07 00:25:06 2007 |
| Michael Johas Teener | |
Abstain | Wed Nov 07 02:23:39 2007 |
| Goetz, Franz-Josef | |
Abstain | Wed Nov 07 02:54:43 2007 |
| Jessy V Rouyer | |
Disapprove | Wed Nov 07 10:46:10 2007 |
| David Elie-Dit-Cosaque | |
Abstain | Wed Nov 07 11:26:31 2007 |
| Panagiotis Saltsidis | |
Abstain | Wed Nov 07 11:29:48 2007 |
| Oliver Thorp | |
Abstain | Wed Nov 07 12:31:36 2007 |
| Ken Young | |
Comments | Wed Nov 07 13:29:15 2007 |
| Hesham Elbakoury | |
Approve | Wed Nov 07 15:40:47 2007 |
| Paul Congdon | |
Disapprove | Wed Nov 07 18:03:47 2007 |
| Bob Sultan | |
Abstain | Wed Nov 07 19:34:21 2007 |
| Pat Thaler | |
Disapprove | Wed Nov 07 22:04:57 2007 |
| Don Fedyk | |
Disapprove | Wed Nov 07 22:17:26 2007 |
| Ken Patton | |
Abstain | Wed Nov 07 22:27:14 2007 |
| Yong Kim | |
Approve | Wed Nov 07 23:36:01 2007 |
| John Terry | |
Abstain | Thu Nov 08 01:35:17 2007 |
| Dinesh Mohan | |
Abstain | Thu Nov 08 03:35:26 2007 |
| Ananda Rajagopal | |
Abstain | Thu Nov 08 13:03:53 2007 |
| Boatright, Robert | |
Abstain | Fri Nov 09 16:35:23 2007 |
| Ali Sajassi (sajassi) | |
Abstain | Sat Nov 10 11:08:38 2007 |
| max pritikin | |
Abstain | Sun Nov 11 10:28:03 2007 |
| Uri Cummings | |
Approve | Mon Nov 12 04:29:51 2007 |
| WIJNEN, Bert (Bert) | |
Disapprove | Mon Nov 12 10:18:24 2007 |
| Frank Chao (fchao) | |
Abstain | Mon Nov 12 13:42:09 2007 |
| Brian Hausauer | |
Abstain | Mon Nov 12 18:25:08 2007 |
| Nurit Sprecher | |
Disapprove | Tue Nov 13 19:44:18 2007 |
| Paul Bottorff | |
No Vote | N/A |
| Edna Ganon | |
No Vote | N/A |
| Ken Grewal | |
No Vote | N/A |
| Tae-Eun Kim | |
No Vote | N/A |
| Kari Laihonen | |
No Vote | N/A |
| David Martin | |
No Vote | N/A |
| John Messenger | |
No Vote | N/A |
| Glenn Parsons | |
No Vote | N/A |
| Neil Peers | |
No Vote | N/A |
| Haim Porat | |
No Vote | N/A |
| Charles Qi | |
No Vote | N/A |
| Allyn Romanow | |
No Vote | N/A |
| Sam Sambasivan | |
No Vote | N/A |
| Himanshu Shah | |
No Vote | N/A |
| Gopi Sirineni | |
No Vote | N/A |
| Zong Wu | |
No Vote | N/A |